Listen & subscribe on iTunes … on Spotify … or anywhere else
You had a sneaking suspicion that with a little work, your voice could be better than you’ve been settling for. So you decided to find some vocal exercises to improve your sound, or make it easier to sing your high notes. You found some, but you discover they are at best, not effective — or at worst they actually create tension, limiting your voice even more and leaving your voice feeling strained even before you begin singing songs! What’s wrong? (Oh yes, there is something definitely wrong!) Here are 4 possible causes:
1. You are doing the wrong exercises for your voice.
Self-prescribing can get you into trouble. Just like pharmaceuticals, there are tons of vocal exercises offered on the internet, on phone apps, and suggested by well-meaning friends. While some of these exercises (done correctly) do work, some of them that have been dreamed up are actually tightening and even damaging. Examples I would say include:
- Contorting your face, tongue or jaw as strenuously as you can. Stretching is good, but stretching any muscle all the way causes your automatic nervous system to apply a ‘knee-jerk’ contraction to prevent tearing. That’s a good way to set up tension and even muscle-spasm at the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). Move your face around and loosen it, yes, but never as radically as possible, and stop before your jaw or face gets tired of stretching.
- Or keeping your face (eyes, jaw) as still as possible. Sorry, once again I find this common admonition counterproductive. To test this yourself, try singing or speaking a short phrase with a frozen face. Then do it again with a very active face such as you would use with a baby or puppy. See what I mean?
- Using vocal fry exercises. Some coaches use this but I find this extremely counterproductive and fatiguing, unless you zip them backwards so your vocal folds are not abused. Definitely don’t use vocal fry in your speaking voice!
- Projecting air pressure for volume, which goes along with a misunderstanding of what ‘healthy belt’ voice is. Your rich and controlled volume should come from a balance of support and control, not just support. Your vocal cords should never feel the air push through them!
2. You are doing healthy vocal exercises but incorrectly with bad form.
Just like any athletic basic skills training, you can hurt yourself trying to help yourself if you don’t know how to do the exercise. For instance:
- You practice tension.
Yes, it’s great to do lip bubbles and tongue trills. But if you push them, even they can cause tension! Why would you want to practice tensing your voice??
- You don’t know how to prepare to travel through your vocal range.
Scales of all kinds can open up your range. But if you don’t know how to ‘lift before you sound’ you’ll push into your highs and lows. And then of course, you’ll perform as you practice.
- You think you’re strengthening your voice by exercising til it hurts.
Just like pumping iron, if you go too far or too long with vocal exercises, you can hurt yourself. Here’s the rule: If it hurts, STOP! No pain is gain when it comes to your voice. It’s OK to stretch and challenge your voice, but not til it hurts!
3. You are warming up your voice too fast.
Use common sense here. Again, like any physical endeavor, if you go from zero to 60 (or even to 5 if you’re really cold), you can create the opposite of a warmup… you can cause a tighten up!
- Yes, your voice wants access to movement. But start slow. Get those tissues flexing and getting some blood flowing before increasing the exercise’s range or level of intensity.
- f you can’t do something yet, DO NOT PUSH ! Just take a calming breath, back up and begin at an earlier place in your warm-up until your voice says ‘yes’ to being challenged.
4. You are not doing your vocal exercises long enough.
If you’ve been singing or touring a lot and your vocal stamina is up, you may need 5 or 10 minutes of warm-up. If you haven’t been singing regularly, have been sick or just have some mucous build-up, you might need 20 to 45 minutes. How do you know? Your voice feels flexible, open and free, and is working like you want it to!
- I recently re-learned the wisdom of taking enough time to completely warm up my voice before performance. I woke up with some gunk coating my throat that seemingly would just not let go. I was afraid I was going to be able to do my lead vocals that day. But I kept on slowly and carefully challenging my voice, finally shook the gunk off, limbered my instrument up and nailed those vocals that day.
- The same thing has happened to me numerous times for stage performance.
- One of my favorite things to do is to have a student begin our lesson with a phlegmy or flabby instrument that isn’t working well, and ending the lesson with the voice feeling warm and flexible, singing the song that would have been impossible at the start!.
- Use common sense and don’t overdo vocal exercises too long or too strenuously if you have a long performance that day. There is a limit to your physical and mental energy, and you’ll need that energy for your vocal main event. Again, at the end of your exercise, your should feel great, not tired!
What can you do?
- Next time you warmup… assess how your voice feels immediately afterwards. If it doesn’t feel great, get to the bottom of ‘why not’.
- If you don’t know HOW to do vocal exercises properly, DON’T DO THEM! Just sing easy songs and do tongue tanglers to warm your voice up.
- Get a trusted vocal coach to teach you how to do vocal exercises that fit your voice.
Remember: your vocal warm-up is not supposed to be a vocal tighten-up!
Need more help?
- Contact me for a vocal lesson.
- Or get a Power, Path and Performance course and learn how to do vocal exercises that work!
greentub says
I've doing the same warm-ups since college (20+ years!). Do I need to revisit this?
Judy Rodman says
Greentub… first of all, congratulations on your dedication to your voice! I'd say ask yourself the questions in the post. How does your voice feel? Would you like to take your vocal ability farther or are you satisfied where you are? But no matter what, I WOULD revisit the way you're doing the exercises you have. Make sure you haven't gotten lazy with form. Thanks for writing!
Terry S. Smith says
Judy, I will reschedule a lesson with you when I get a couple of weeks of regularly preparing for the visit so you can see how your exercises are helping. I am recording reading things both the Psalms and poetry I am writing. Tomorrow night I will sing "The Impossible Dream" at New Years Party so I am warming up and going through some of the exercises. Do you think it is possible I could do a CD of favorite songs for the family for Christmas 2015? Charlotte's book is out and she plans to give you one. "A Transplanted Soul." I think it is absolutely wonderful. I, also, cannot wait to hear the CD you and John have completed. I love your work and the blessed gift you are to all the ones who are priviledged to work with you. We love you. Terry and Charlotte
Judy Rodman says
YES absolutely you can do that CD for Christmas, Terrry! Can't wait to help you do it. Very much looking forward to Charlotte's poetry book, too. Will trade for our CD:) Love and Happy New Year to both of you… from our house to yours!
Catriona says
I often find without warmups my range is still good and I can do songs easiest. I do want to follow doing warmups before singing however I always feel like my voice becomes dry and less flexible maybe even a little hoarse this doesn’t always happen though only sometimes. I haven’t found a warmup that works I’ve been trying lip trills, sirens mostly and alongside humming warmups and yawning and lengthening jaw. However in the past singing lessons have been expensive and haven’t worked well for me as it leaves me more struggling than before the lesson.
Catriona says
I know what I’ve said but do you have any advice on how I can find the perfect warmup and perhaps be able to warmup without having the undesired results.
Judy Rodman says
Catriona, you are exactly the kind of vocalist I wrote this post for. I'm glad you've realized something is wrong. Vocal exercises absolutely should NOT make your voice feel hoarse, dry or less flexible! Please take to heart what I've said here in this post. My best advice for you is either 1. don't DO vocal exercises because you're not doing the right ones correctly, or 2. get a vocal lesson from a teacher who can help you. Yes, a good teacher can be expensive (my lessons are $125 hr or $65 for 1/2 hr) but even one lesson from a good, intuitive teacher should help you a lot. If you'd like to contact me, email me at [email protected]. I wish you the very best in figuring out your best solution.